When bettors start looking for broker access to Pinnacle and Asian bookmakers, two names come up quickly alongside AsianConnect: BetInAsia and MadMarket. Both solve the same core problem (giving professional bettors access to sharp books without account restrictions), but they position themselves slightly differently.
Choosing between them is not always obvious from their websites. This comparison covers the practical differences: what each broker actually provides, what it costs, and which bettor type each is best suited for.
BetInAsia and MadMarket at a Glance
BetInAsia
A specialist Asian betting broker known for Pinnacle access and Asian book depth. Stake-based commission model (~1%). Strong focus on professional bettors needing access to the Asian betting ecosystem from restricted jurisdictions including Ireland. Established operator with a reputation for transparent pricing.
MadMarket
A broader-access broker with Pinnacle and Asian book access alongside additional operator options. Commission operates at 1–2% depending on market and volume. Positioned for bettors who want to consolidate multiple operator access through a single account, alongside the core Pinnacle and SBO suite.
BetInAsia vs MadMarket : Full Comparison
| Criterion | BetInAsia | MadMarket |
|---|---|---|
| Commission model | Stake-based (~1%) | Stake/winnings-based (1–2%, varies by market) |
| Pinnacle access | Yes | Yes |
| SBO/ISN/MaxBet access | Yes | Yes |
| Exchange access | Yes (select exchanges) | Yes (select exchanges) |
| Ireland registrations | Accepted | Accepted |
| Deposit methods | Bank transfer (SEPA/SWIFT) | Bank transfer (SEPA/SWIFT) |
| Volume discounts | Available for active accounts | On request |
| Asian Handicap markets | Full: Pinnacle + Asian book suite | Full: Pinnacle + Asian book suite |
| Account restrictions | None (institutional account model) | None (institutional account model) |
| Minimum deposit | ~€100–€200 (confirm with broker) | Confirm with broker |
| Primary positioning | Pinnacle + Asian book specialist | Broader operator access |
Who Should Use BetInAsia and Who Should Use MadMarket?
Choose BetInAsia If...
- Your primary need is Pinnacle access from Ireland
- You want a transparent stake-based commission model (~1%)
- You are focused on the core Asian book suite (Pinnacle, SBO, ISN, MaxBet)
- You prefer a broker with a specialist Asian focus and established reputation
- You want predictable, calculable commission on every bet
Choose MadMarket If...
- You want broader operator access beyond the core Asian suite
- You prefer a broker that bundles multiple operator types in a single account
- Commission flexibility and volume negotiation is a priority
- You are already familiar with Asian brokers and want a second option to compare
- You want to consolidate betting across multiple books in one funded account
Commission Compared : Real Cost on Typical Stakes
The headline commission rates are similar between BetInAsia (~1%) and MadMarket (1–2%). The practical difference at moderate volumes is small but compounding. Here is what the commission difference looks like on €100,000 in annual stakes:
| Annual Staking | BetInAsia @ 1% | MadMarket @ 1% | MadMarket @ 1.5% |
|---|---|---|---|
| €50,000 | €500 | €500 | €750 |
| €100,000 | €1,000 | €1,000 | €1,500 |
| €250,000 | €2,500 | €2,500 | €3,750 |
If MadMarket's commission on your specific markets is 1% (matching BetInAsia), the total cost is identical. If it is 1.5%, the difference grows with volume. At €100,000 per year, the gap is €500. At €250,000 per year, it is €1,250. Commission rate matters most at high volume: ask each broker specifically about rates for your intended betting activity before opening an account.
Market Access : What Each Broker Actually Provides
Both BetInAsia and MadMarket provide access to the same core Asian book set: Pinnacle, SBO (SBOBet), ISN, and MaxBet. These are the key books for Asian Handicap markets, sharp football odds, and high-liquidity pre-match betting. For bettors in Ireland, this access is the primary reason to use a broker: it resolves the country restriction wall that Pinnacle and SBO enforce for direct registrations.
The difference between the two brokers in practice is likely to be in the secondary operators they provide access to, and in execution quality: order processing speed, minimum/maximum stake sizes per market, and how efficiently large orders are handled. These are factors you will experience in use rather than on paper.
For a broader view of which broker provides access to which bookmakers and exchanges, see our pages on bookmakers available via brokers and exchanges available via brokers.
Frequently Asked Questions : BetInAsia vs MadMarket
What is the main difference between BetInAsia and MadMarket?
BetInAsia is a specialist Asian bookmaker broker with a strong focus on Pinnacle and the core Asian book suite (SBO, ISN, MaxBet). MadMarket positions itself more broadly, with access to a similar Asian book set alongside additional operator options. For bettors whose primary need is Pinnacle access from Ireland with transparent stake-based commission, BetInAsia is purpose-built. For bettors wanting a wider range of operator access through a single account, MadMarket is a credible alternative.
Which broker has lower commission, BetInAsia or MadMarket?
Both brokers operate in the 1–2% commission range on stakes. BetInAsia typically quotes ~1% for standard markets. MadMarket operates at 1–2% depending on market and volume. Commission rates can be negotiated at higher volumes at both brokers. The right comparison is not commission rate in isolation, but total cost of betting: commission plus the quality of odds you receive on the underlying book.
Do both BetInAsia and MadMarket accept Irish accounts?
Yes. Both BetInAsia and MadMarket accept registrations from Ireland and provide access to Pinnacle, which does not accept Irish registrations directly. For bettors based in Ireland who want Pinnacle access, both are valid solutions. The choice between them comes down to commission structure, the specific books they provide access to, and your personal experience during account setup.
Is BetInAsia or MadMarket better for Pinnacle access?
Both brokers provide access to Pinnacle. BetInAsia has historically been closely associated with Pinnacle access and Asian book depth. MadMarket also provides Pinnacle access. The practical difference is likely to be commission rate and the secondary books you can access on the same account, which matters if you want to diversify across Pinnacle, SBO, and other Asian operators from a single funded account.
Can I use both BetInAsia and MadMarket at the same time?
Yes. There is no restriction on opening accounts with multiple brokers simultaneously. Some professional bettors do this to compare execution, test commission rates, or access different secondary books. The practical consideration is maintaining funded balances across multiple accounts, which adds operational overhead. Most bettors start with one broker and add a second if specific needs arise.
Which broker is easier to open an account with?
Both brokers have a similar account opening process: application, KYC document submission, and bank transfer deposit. Neither is significantly harder to open than the other. The key variable is your individual document situation and the broker's current onboarding volume, which affects verification time more than the difficulty of the process itself.